WBE: Which method is fastest?

March 31, 2023

Sample processing for measuring SARS-CoV-2 RNA in wastewater involves sample preparation, sample concentration, RNA extraction and RNA measurement methods. Methods selected at each step must be tailored for use with wastewater, which is a chemically and biologically complex and variable mixture. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends evaluating the performance of these wastewater sample processing procedures using appropriate laboratory controls.

Collecting wastewater samples

Concentration approaches evaluated to date that yield adequate recovery for SARS-CoV-2 detection in wastewater include:

  • Ultrafiltration
  • Filtration through an electronegative membrane with sample pre-treatment by addition of MgCl2 or acidification
  • Polyethylene glycol (PEG) precipitation
  • Skimmed milk flocculation
  • Ultracentrifugation

The CDC says to consider the following factors when selecting a virus concentration method:

  • Sample type: For untreated wastewater samples, several filtration and precipitation methods, listed above, are available. For primary sludge samples, centrifugation is the most effective way to concentrate solids.
  • Sample volume: Large untreated wastewater sample volumes may require dividing the sample prior to membrane filtration (due to slow filtration rate) or PEG precipitation (due to centrifuge volume constraints). Sample volumes greater than 5 L may require pre-concentration by methods designed to concentrate a large volume, such as large cartridge ultrafiltration.
  • Potential supply chain issues: Methods that require commercial filtration products, such as membrane filters or ultrafiltration cartridges, may be more sensitive to supply chain issues than other methods.
  • Sample processing time: Concentration method selection will be constrained by method processing time and availability of laboratory personnel. Membrane filtration of turbid wastewater samples may take several hours.
  • Availability of laboratory equipment: Centrifuge volumes and force capacity, as well as availability of membrane filtration units, will also constrain method selection.

Nucleic acid extraction and purification is an essential step in isolating SARS-CoV-2 RNA from the sewage mixture. Sewage is a complex mixture with materials known to interfere with molecular viral quantification methods, so consider the following when selecting an extraction method:

  • Select an extraction protocol designed to produce highly purified nucleic acid extracts from environmental samples. Commercial kits are available for environmental sample extraction.
  • Use an extraction kit or a protocol that is designed specifically to purify RNA and includes RNase denaturants prior to lysis.
  • Avoid degradation of extracted RNA due to multiple freeze-thaw cycles by aliquoting extracts into separate tubes and storing them at -70 °C or below.

Nanotrap® Microbiome Particles from Streck provide a simple and rapid approach for concentration of microbes from various sample types. They utilize affinity capture and enrichment technology to bind low abundance targets. The particles concentrate microbes from 24 wastewater samples in 40 minutes, faster than other automated methods such as PEG precipitation or ultracentrifugation.

Are you searching for a fast WBE program? We put two methods in the ring for the lab match of the century!

Nanotrap Microbiome Particles vs PEG Precipitation

In one corner we have the swift newcomer Nanotrap® Microbiome Particles — and in the other, heavy-hitting, slower-than-slow veteran PEG precipitation. They will battle for the title of fastest and most efficient method to capture and concentrate microorganisms from your complex wastewater-based epidemiology samples. 

When the bell sounds, Nanotrap Microbiome Particles land time saving blows in your lab with lightning-fast performance. The particles streamline your sample processing protocol — capture and concentrate 24 samples in 42.5 minutes (manual). Old-timer PEG precipitation can take up to 21 hours! 

Total Time for Nanotrap Microbiome Particles
Total time for PEG precipitation

The clear winner of this smackdown in the lab is Nanotrap Microbiome Particles!

Click here to view The WBE Smackdown comparison of the Nanotrap Microbiome Particles procedures vs. PEG Precipitation.

Read the procedure comparison

Are you ready to speak with a rep?

Select the state where your lab is located to find your rep and book a time for a personalized phone call.

Nanotrap® Microbiome Particles (For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures.), distributed by Streck, offer a simple and rapid approach for concentration of SARS-Co-V-2 from large volume wastewater samples.

Nanotrap Microbiome A Particles

Webinar: What Lies Beneath: Wastewater Testing for Pathogens

Wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) is a powerful tool for monitoring the emergence of infectious pathogens. While WBE has been around since the 1800s…
Read More

Preventing infections in dialysis patients

A recent report published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention outlines the challenges faced by 800,000 people in the United States who a…
Read More

CDC updates AR investment map

AR occurs when germs are unresponsive to drugs and other chemotherapies designed to kill them. AR threatens to return the world to a time when even si…
Read More